IMC 2008: Sessions
Session 1111: Concepts of the Self in the 11th and 12th Centuries
Wednesday 9 July 2008, 11.15-12.45
Organiser: | Franz-Josef Arlinghaus, Instituts für Geschichte & historische Landesforschung, Hochschule Vechta |
---|---|
Moderator/Chair: | Michael Clanchy, Institute of Historical Research, University of London |
Paper 1111-a | Voices of a Visionary: Elisabeth of Schönau, Ekbert of Schönau, and the Rhetorics of the Individual (Language: English) Index terms: Gender Studies, Mentalities, Monasticism, Science |
Paper 1111-b | Murmur against God and Religious Doubt: Unwelcome Individual Experiences in the High and Late Middle Ages (Language: English) Index terms: Mentalities, Monasticism, Religious Life |
Paper 1111-c | Abelard, the Paraklet-Monastery, and Heloise: Individuality and Relationships in the 12th Century (Language: English) Index terms: Gender Studies, Mentalities, Monasticism, Religious Life |
Abstract | The discussion about the medieval self has for a long time focussed on drawing a line between the presumed starting-point of individuality in the 12th century and modern individuality. While research has rightly shown that it is wrong to believe that medieval people were not aware or had 'underdeveloped' concepts of themselves, one could, on the other hand, question the strong teleological component of the discussion. Therefore, the session tries to focus on the differences and peculiarities of 12th-century individuality rather than on the similarities. One central aspect of these differences may be seen in the specific way people constructed their relationships to God and to others, and in the importance these relationships have as points of reference for the construction of individuality. The idea is that, while in terms of self-consciousness and self-awareness, we find a lot of similarities to modern concepts, in the way people relate themselves to others or to the world as a whole and the importance they attribute to such relations, the differences are striking. |