IMC 2009: Sessions
Session 1023: Thinking through the World: Transcendence and Necessity
Wednesday 15 July 2009, 09.00-10.30
Moderator/Chair: | Mariele Nientied, Kulturwissenschaftliche Fakultät, Europa Universität Viadrina, Frankfurt an der Oder |
---|---|
Paper 1023-a | The Patristic Sources of Boethius's Consolation of Philosophy (Language: English) Index terms: Philosophy, Theology |
Paper 1023-b | The Worldly Path to Transcendence (Language: English) Index terms: Mentalities, Monasticism, Philosophy, Science |
Paper 1023-c | Naturalistic Theology and Particularism (Language: English) Index terms: Hebrew and Jewish Studies, Medievalism and Antiquarianism, Theology |
Abstract | Paper -a: Paper -b: Paper-c: Adherents of the view, for philosophical reasons, of God as an Unchanging Perfection, struggle with the issue of God's relations to particulars. Can an unchanging perfection choose a particular group, a particular creed, particular human actions, or even particular divine responses? If God as unchanging perfection is above such particulars, then how can any religion make an exclusive truth claim? Thus, this philosophical idea of God can undermine the orthodox claims of a religion. A number of Jewish thinkers have tried to get around this problem, at least in part, by making naturalistic claims for the exclusive truth of Judaism, often focusing on its unfolding in consonance with various astral forces, historical factors, etc. I shall briefly examine some such claims made by Judah HaLevi, Maimonides, and Samuel Ibn Matut, finding a general pattern, then ask whether their approaches leave room for the possibility of other religions being as true, and finally touch upon the question of to what degree they relegate God to non-engagement with particulars. |