Skip to main content

IMC 2011: Sessions

Session 1523: Authority and Social Status: A Question of Money?

Thursday 14 July 2011, 09.00-10.30

Moderator/Chair:Michael H. Gelting, Centre for Scandinavian Studies King's College University of Aberdeen 24 High Street OLD ABERDEEN AB24 3EB
Paper 1523-aPrimores and Vulgus in 12th- and 13th-Century Denmark
(Language: English)
Philip Walter Line, Independent Scholar, Helsinki
Index terms: Historiography - Medieval, Language and Literature - Scandinavian, Social History
Paper 1523-b'They must remain where they belong to': Critique against the Appearance of Low-Born Men as Officials in the Royal Court
(Language: English)
Ayşegül Keskin Çolak, University of Birmingham
Index terms: Language and Literature - Middle English, Language and Literature - Latin
Paper 1523-cThe Association of Authority and Fortune in the Social Groups of the Elite in Norway and France of the 13th Century
(Language: English)
Evgeniya Shelina, Department of Nordic Studies, Paris-Sorbonne Université - Paris IV
Index terms: Law, Mentalities, Political Thought, Social History
Abstract

Paper -a:
To many nowadays it seems self-evident that social structure in the Middle Ages was based upon wealth and military power, but that was not necessarily how medieval people perceived it. Saxo, and to a lesser extent Sven Aggesen and the Icelandic author of Knytlinga saga, equated those who were entitled to power and riches with those who had honour and civic and military virtue, whilst representing other groups (often seen as one group, populares or plebs) as fractious, gullible, greedy and disruptive to general order. This paper will look these attitudes in the light of other sources for Danish history of the 12th and 13th centuries, such as the law codes and letters, and question whether the privileged had any empathy at all with those who were less fortunate.

Paper -b:
Although the distinction between the poor and the rich was indisputably clear throughout the middle ages, there appeared from the 12th-century onwards some cases where low-born men managed to climb the social ladder through recruitment as officials in royal courts. However, this kind of mobility in the rigid class structure of medieval England caused heated criticism, if not attack, among the clerical strand of the courtly milieu. In this paper, I will discuss the emergence of this criticism among 12th-century courtly clerics in the court of Henry II of England as a topos in the genre of court satire.

Paper -c:
In the proposed paper we are analyzing the controversial nature of the relations between the two attributive characteristics of the Norwegian and the French elites of the 13th century: fortune and authority. We will focus on the alterations of the financial status that occurred both inside the elite and in its relations to the whole society. Our analysis of the structures of power is based on several criteria: personal and quantitative variations of the group membership, the structural and functional connections inside the elite. The proposed comparative analysis validates the question of similarity and singularity of the historical processes considered.